The distinctions between language, dialect, and accent aren’t always clear-cut. A technical definition can be applied to each one — with accent perhaps being the easiest to differentiate — but there is a certain amount of overlap among the three linguistic classifications. Human communication is, after all, an incredibly fluid and ever-evolving process.
When we talk about accent, we are referring specifically to differences in pronunciation — how words sound when spoken aloud, or, as Merriam-Webster puts it, “an individual’s distinctive or characteristic inflection, tone, or choice of words.” We all speak with an accent (even if our accent is considered “neutral” for our particular language). Someone might speak the exact same language and use identical vocabulary and grammar as us, but they might still pronounce words differently — i.e., have an accent — based on their geographic origin or social background. In the United States, notable accents include those from New York City, Boston, and the South (which has its own variations, depending on the location). A person from Boston and someone from Alabama may both speak English, but their distinct accents sound different. In this case, the accent alone is unlikely to affect overall comprehension — but particularly strong accents can hinder a listener’s understanding, especially when combined with a difference in dialect.
Accents can be understood as a subset of dialect. Dialects are more complicated than accents in that they encompass differences that include not only pronunciation but also vocabulary, grammar, and sentence structure. Dialects represent regional or social varieties of the same language, and due to their unique vocabulary and grammatical features, dialects can hinder understanding between speakers of the same language, especially if they are not accustomed to the differences. A good example is Scouse, the distinctive dialect (and accent) of Liverpool and the Merseyside region of the United Kingdom. People from the U.S. might struggle to understand Scouse, even though it’s a dialect of English. Even east Londoners who speak their own Cockney dialect of English can struggle with Scouse — and Liverpool is only 200 miles away from London. However, spending time immersed in the dialect will familiarize someone with the new way of speaking.
The broadest of the three linguistic categories is language. Language represents a complete communication system with its own vocabulary, grammar rules, and often writing system — it includes dialects and accents. The general test for whether two communication systems constitute separate languages is mutual intelligibility: If speakers cannot understand each other without specific learning of the grammar, vocabulary, and syntax by both parties, they’re speaking different languages rather than distinct dialects. But the precise boundaries of what constitutes a separate language are not always easy to define, existing on a scale of difference rather than either side of a clear dividing line.
More from our network
Word Smarts is part of Optimism, which publishes content that uplifts, informs, and inspires.
